Aston Villa – Newcastle: Villa Resilient with Ten, Newcastle Toothless Without Isak (0-0)

The opening weekend of the Premier League delivered a gripping, if goalless, affair as Aston Villa battled to a hard-fought 0-0 draw against Newcastle United at Villa Park. The match was a compelling tale of two halves, with Newcastle asserting their dominance and control from the start. 

Tactical analysis and match report by Aderemi Qoyum.

Aston Villa and Newcastle opened their Premier League campaigns with contrasting narratives. Villa, constrained by PSR restrictions but buoyed by last season’s European push, looked to start strong under Unai Emery’s disciplined, counter-attacking approach. Newcastle, missing star striker Alexander Isak, aimed to prove their growing stature with an opening-day statement. The clash promised Villa’s defensive resilience against Newcastle’s attacking intent, setting up a fiercely competitive encounter from the first whistle.

Aston Villa lined up in a 4-2-3-1 with debutant Marco Bizot in goal, shielded by a back four of Matty Cash, Lucas Digne, Ezri Konsa, and Tyrone Mings. In midfield, Boubacar Kamara and Amadou Onana formed a double pivot, focused on both protecting the defense and controlling the tempo. Youri Tielemans operated as the central playmaker, flanked by Morgan Rogers on the left, who frequently drifted into the half-space, and John McGinn on the right, bringing energy and creativity. Ollie Watkins led the attack as the lone striker, tasked with stretching Newcastle’s back line through pace and relentless movement.

Newcastle United lined up in a 4-3-3 built around possession and high pressing, with goalkeeper Nick Pope protected by a back four of Kieran Trippier, Valentino Livramento, Dan Burn, and Fabian Schär. In midfield, Sandro Tonali anchored the trio, flanked by Bruno Guimarães and Joelinton. The front three featured Anthony Elanga, Harvey Barnes, and Anthony Gordon filling in as the central striker in the absence of Alexander Isak. Their clear strategy was to dominate possession, press Villa high, and use the pace of their attack to exploit spaces behind the defensive line.

Newcastle Takes Control

The first half was a testament to Newcastle’s tactical dominance and an illustration of Aston Villa’s struggle to find their rhythm. From the opening whistle, Newcastle seized control, deploying a high-intensity press that stifled Villa’s build-up play and forced them into a number of hurried clearances and turnovers. The Magpies’ physical midfield trio of Tonali, Guimarães, and Joelinton operated with a palpable energy, snapping into tackles and winning the ball back in dangerous areas.

The pressure almost paid off within the first three minutes. A fluid move saw Newcastle bypass Villa’s midfield, and a perfectly weighted through ball from Tonali sent summer signing Anthony Elanga through on goal. With only the debutant keeper to beat, Elanga’s shot was tame and directed straight at Marco Bizot, who made a crucial save with his feet to deny the new man a dream start. This was a warning shot that Villa’s defensive line was vulnerable to Newcastle’s blistering pace.

Newcastle continued to turn the screw, with their wingers proving to be a constant threat. Harvey Barnes and Elanga consistently looked to cut inside or drive to the byline, and Anthony Gordon, playing as a false nine, showed great movement to link up with his teammates. The statistics at halftime painted a clear picture of the one-sided nature of the contest, with Newcastle dominating possession and accumulating a number of shots, while Aston Villa’s expected goals (xG) was virtually non-existent with 0.00xG generated.

Aston Villa’s attempts to transition into attack were largely thwarted. Ollie Watkins, isolated up top, was forced to chase long balls over the top, which were comfortably dealt with by the imposing central defensive pairing of Dan Burn and Fabian Schär. The home side’s midfield struggled to get a foothold in the game, with Tielemans unable to find the space to create, and the double pivot of Kamara and Onana constantly on the back foot.

Minute 22’ Newcastle United’s high-intensity press against Aston Villa’s 4-2-3-1 formation in the first half. Elanga tucking inside to press Mings with Trippier stepping up to Digne from right back, keeping a 3v3 in midfield. A coordinated pressure from Newcastle’s front three and midfield trio, showcasing their objective to win the ball back high up the pitch and force turnovers.

The Magpies’ dominance was not just a result of their pressing, but also their intelligent use of width. The full-backs, Kieran Trippier and Valentino Livramento, at times pushed high up the flanks, creating overloads and providing constant crossing threats. Livramento tucked into the half-space more, keeping Barnes 1v1 against Matty Cash. Aston Villa responded to this constant pressure by sitting deep with as many players as possible. They sometimes went so defensive that they had a back six or seven with Onana and the wingers joining the defensive line to avoid any risk of overloads both centrally and in the wide areas. The first half ended with Aston Villa fortunate to be on level terms, saved only by some crucial defending and the debut heroics of Marco Bizot.

Minute 24’ Avoid overloads Villa sitting in a 7-3-0 defensive shape with McGinn, Rogers and Onana joining the back four while also avoiding the possible overload by the trio of Elanga, Trippier and Bruno Guimaraes on the left side of their defence. Villa were protected centrally by Tielemans, Kamara and Watkins in front of the defence.

Villa’s Ten-Man Stand

The second half began with a slightly more composed Aston Villa, who had clearly received tactical instructions from Unai Emery to tighten up their defensive shape. They looked to play out from the back with a little more purpose, and Ollie Watkins had a rare sight of goal in the 65th minute, forcing a comfortable save from Nick Pope. However, just a minute later, the entire complexion of the match changed dramatically.

A rapid attacking transition from Newcastle saw a superb, defense-splitting pass from Anthony Elanga to send Anthony Gordon racing through on goal. Gordon had a clear run on goal, but was dragged back by Ezri Konsa with what seemed like a professional foul that eventually paid off. Referee Craig Pawson had no hesitation, brandishing a straight red card for the denial of an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. The decision was confirmed by VAR, leaving Aston Villa to face the final 24 minutes of the game with just ten men.

Unai Emery immediately reacted to the dismissal, making key tactical adjustments. He sacrificed an attacking player and moved to a compact defensive shape, with Boubacar Kamara dropping back to partner Tyrone Mings in a make-shift central defense, and the remaining players forming a narrow and disciplined low block. The message was clear: defend the point at all costs.

Newcastle, now with a significant numerical advantage, began to dominate even more. They pinned Aston Villa back into their own half, creating a continuous wave of attacks. The Magpies’ xG, already high, began to swell as they looked to break down Villa’s deep-lying defense. The best chance of the half fell to Harvey Barnes, who received the ball inside the box and unleashed a powerful volley towards goal, only for an outstretched leg from Matty Cash to produce a magnificent, goal-saving block.

Despite all their possession and chances, Newcastle’s final ball was often lacking, and they visibly missed the clinical finishing of the absent Alexander Isak. Anthony Gordon, while showing great movement and pace, was not a natural number nine, and his finishing was not as ruthless. The Magpies resorted to a number of shots from outside the box, but the combination of a resolute Villa defense and the superb goalkeeping of Marco Bizot ensured they were kept at bay.

Minute 73’ Aston Villa’s 10-man compact 4-4-1 defensive block in the final stages of the match. Boubacar Kamara’s new position as a right central defender alongside Tyrone Mings and the team’s collective commitment to denying Newcastle space in the final third. In this setup, Watkins was again let isolated up top to do almost it alone in transition while Joelinton played more like a secondary forward alongside Gordon for more aerial presence in the box.

The match ended with a relieved Aston Villa celebrating a hard-earned point, while Newcastle’s players looked on in frustration, ruing their missed opportunities.

Takeaways

Aston Villa’s debutant goalkeeper Marco Bizot was the standout performer, making key saves to secure a hard-fought point. Newcastle dominated, especially after Villa’s red card, but their wastefulness in front of goal exposed the absence of Alexander Isak. Eddie Howe will take positives from the team’s energy and structure but knows a clinical striker is needed to compete at the top. Unai Emery, meanwhile, will be delighted with his side’s resilience and tactical adaptability, particularly in coping with ten men.

Use the arrows to scroll through all available match plots. Click to enlarge.
Check the match plots page for plots of other matches.