Arsenal – Manchester City: Humbled and Crumbled (5-1)

This game was one for the history books for a number of reasons. The anticipation surrounding the Emirates Stadium was immense, and Arsenal certainly lived up to the hype. They made Manchester City look ordinary and ultimately dominated the game with their ruthlessness both in and out of possession.

Tactical analysis and match report by Rahul Madhavan.

We decided to make this article free to read. If you want to support our work, consider taking a subscription.


Erling Haaland’s infamous “Stay Humble” comments in the reverse fixture and the reaction they sparked certainly set the stage for a massive showdown at the Emirates. However, the broader context revolved around Arsenal responding to Liverpool’s victory over AFC Bournemouth earlier. A defeat would have widened the gap significantly, potentially making it insurmountable, but Mikel Arteta’s side entered the game in solid form, having won three consecutive matches across all competitions.

Arteta had the luxury of resting key players in the Champions League, allowing him to field his strongest possible starting lineup on Sunday. David Raya returned in goal, with a back four of Jurriën Timber, William Saliba, Gabriel Magalhães, and Myles Lewis-Skelly. In midfield, Thomas Partey and Declan Rice started behind Martin Ødegaard, while Gabriel Martinelli, Leandro Trossard, and Kai Havertz formed the front three.

Manchester City, meanwhile, had climbed back into the top four last week after an important victory over Chelsea. After a difficult couple of months, City had regained some momentum in the Premier League, as they arrived at this game on a six-match unbeaten run, including four wins. The reigning champions, though not favorites, would have certainly aimed to derail Arsenal’s title charge once again. More importantly, they sought a confidence boost ahead of a challenging run of fixtures this month.

In terms of team selection, Guardiola was without Ederson due to injury, with Stefan Ortega stepping in. The same backline that started against Club Brugge kept their place due to City’s limited defensive options. In midfield, Bernardo Silva and Mateo Kovačić started, while Omar Marmoush was given the nod over Kevin De Bruyne. Up front, Savinho earned a start, pushing İlkay Gündoğan to the bench, while Phil Foden and Erling Haaland led the attack.


Gunners go with early aggressive press

Arsenal haven’t lost to City in their past three meetings, but in all those games, there was a sense of passiveness in their usually high press. This could largely be attributed to City’s ability to play out from the back and the looming threat of Haaland up front if they decided to press aggressively from the outset.

However, this time, Arteta recognized that the best moment to attack City was early in the game, given their struggles to build up effectively. With Ederson sidelined as well, Arsenal had the intention to trouble City from the first minute and certainly picked their moments brilliantly.

Guardiola opted to play a back three in possession, with the goalkeeper essentially acting as a central defender. As a result, City’s back three spread out while Kovačić and Silva dropped deeper but in staggered lines. With Nunes pushing higher up, City had Haaland taking the attention of Saliba and Gabriel, while Foden and Marmoush were ready to pounce on any knockdowns from the center-forward. Arsenal’s setup saw Havertz initiating the press while Ødegaard and Rice stayed tight to City’s pivot. Once the goalkeeper moved the ball to the free center-back (usually Stones), the hosts shifted across, with Ødegaard stepping up to press.

City simply struggled to bypass Arsenal’s aggressive press, and that pressure paid off early for the Gunners. Stones’ square pass to Akanji saw the Swiss international fail to control it properly, allowing Trossard to intercept. Havertz then went through on goal and squared it to Ødegaard, who made it 1-0 inside the first two minutes.


Minute 1: Arsenal’s shape out of possession. After the initial press from Havertz, Ødegaard was quick to close down Stones. Trossard, who initially positioned himself deeper to cover a switch to Nunes, read the play and immediately pressed Akanji. The ball deflected to Rice after the interception, leading to the goal.


Now, there are valid questions about whether Stones should have played that pass to Akanji in the first place. The staggered lines that Silva and Kovačić operated in certainly had the potential to disrupt Arsenal’s press, at least to some degree. In that scenario, Silva drifted across, and Rice hesitated, scanning for support. If City had a left-footed center-back, there was space to pick out Silva, given how Ødegaard angled his run to block the passing lane to Kovačić.

Consequently, it was rather surprising to see Stones positioned there ahead of Akanji, who certainly has more experience playing in that role. In the opening minutes, City struggled in build-up situations largely because Stones found it difficult to pick out passing lanes to Marmoush and Savinho. His body positioning also primarily favored passes to the right side, limiting his options.

However, credit must ultimately go to Arsenal. They deliberately shut down passing options and identified the key players and angles to target. After the first goal, Arteta quickly noticed City’s hesitancy in possession. Trossard initially positioned himself deeper, but given Ortega’s struggles with long passes, the Belgian pushed forward to mark Akanji, while Havertz closed down the goalkeeper from the right side. This further restricted City’s options and forced Ortega to play long, where Arsenal had Saliba, Gabriel, and Partey dominating the first and second balls.


Manchester City fail to take tactical advantage

City weathered the early storm, and once the dust settled, Arsenal—holding a one-goal advantage—were content to sit in a medium-block. With Haaland almost always marked by two defenders, the visitors naturally had a numerical advantage elsewhere. That advantage came in midfield, thanks to Guardiola’s adaptation of a 3-4-3 diamond-shaped structure, a system he has used in the past.

With Marmoush and Foden positioned in the half-spaces, Silva was given the license to push forward and form the tip of the diamond. At times, the Portuguese midfielder’s movement was highly flexible, as he drifted both to the left and, in particular, to the right to create overloads. This posed a dilemma for Arsenal, particularly for Declan Rice. While Partey stayed tight on Marmoush, Rice was tasked with tracking Foden. The issue arose when Silva consistently moved into pockets, creating a two-versus-one advantage for City in that area.

Initially, the Gunners countered by using Trossard to support Rice, but they were occasionally caught out when attempting to press higher up the pitch. However, City’s problem was that even when they progressed into midfield, they were often forced to move the ball wide, primarily to Matheus Nunes. Unlike a direct one-versus-one threat that would force Arsenal to shift across quickly, Nunes lacked that capability.

Instead, Arsenal were comfortable retreating into a compact shape, allowing Nunes time on the ball. Given City’s reluctance to put crosses into the box due to the threat of break aways, Arsenal remained largely untroubled.


Minute 33: Ødegaard initiated the press on Stones, but Kovačić’s intelligent movement provided City access to the center. This forced Rice to push forward, creating space for Foden to receive on the turn. With Silva positioned in the pockets, City had a three-versus-two advantage on the right, but Myles Lewis-Skelly remained compact, allowing Nunes time on the ball while Arsenal retreated quickly. This ultimately led to City recycling possession back to the center-backs and losing momentum.


City also frequently switched play through Kovačić and Stones, attempting to exploit their numerical advantage on the right flank. However, Arsenal recognized the real danger, shut down the central areas, and were once again content to allow Nunes have possession in wide areas. The makeshift full-back failed to complete any of his six attempted crosses, which certainly highlighted City’s struggles to create chances from open play.


The progressive passes plot revealed City’s preference to move the ball to the right flank after receiving in central areas. Nunes also had the highest number of progressive passes received, indicating Arsenal’s approach of allowing the Portuguese midfielder to have possession in less threatening positions.


Ironically, City’s equalizer stemmed from this very dynamic—but with a clever variation. Savinho drifted inside before switching the ball to the free man, Nunes. Nunes then found Foden in the half-space, who spotted Savinho’s movement into the right channel and picked him out—completely unmarked. Savinho’s pinpoint cross found Haaland, who clinically buried his first and only chance of the game.


Manchester City’s familiar struggles resurface

At 1-1 around the hour mark, the game was set up for a thrilling finish, but City’s struggles this season have largely stemmed from their own mistakes. And that’s exactly what happened to shift the momentum of the game. Just a minute after the visitors equalized, Foden carelessly conceded possession, allowing Partey to pounce. City then failed to close down the midfielder, whose shot deflected off Stones and found the back of the net.

It was Arsenal’s turn to seize the momentum, and they did so with vigor. The positional rotations, particularly on the left side between Trossard, Rice, Lewis-Skelly, and Ødegaard, were evident and caused significant problems for City. Both Rice and Lewis-Skelly combined for the third goal, with the 18-year-old receiving on the turn and curling one into the net with his weaker foot to put the game out of City’s reach.

This has been a recurring issue for Manchester City this season—they have shown signs of vulnerability after making mistakes. Guardiola reacted to going two goals down by bringing on Kevin De Bruyne and James McAtee while instructing both full-backs to push higher in an attempt to pin Arsenal back. However, this approach had the opposite effect, as it exposed their already fragile counter-press, while also highlighting their season-long struggles against fast breaks. That’s precisely how Arsenal added their fourth goal.


Minute 72: Manchester City committed numbers forward, creating another right-sided overload. As Kovačić picked out Savinho, the Brazilian lost possession, allowing Arsenal to counter. The loose ball fell to Partey, and with De Bruyne failing to engage him, the Ghanaian quickly released Martinelli. This led to a two-versus-two situation, with Havertz rounding off the counter-attack to exploit City’s poor rest defense.


While Arsenal’s very own Myles Lewis-Skelly scored what seemed like the decisive goal, another gem from the academy, Ethan Nwaneri, delivered the icing on the cake with a stunning fifth goal late in the game. On a night when they needed to make a statement, the Gunners were clinical, punishing Manchester City by putting five past a Pep Guardiola team for only the second time in history.


Takeaways

There was much to admire about this Arsenal performance. Their early aggression immediately put City on the back foot. After scoring, their ability to adopt a medium block and give City a false sense of comfort—without ever looking genuinely troubled—was another standout aspect. Lastly, their ruthlessness in punishing City’s errors sealed what was a statement victory. Questions have been raised about Arsenal in the past, but perhaps it’s time to fully acknowledge Arteta’s ability to consistently set his team up for different game states and come out on top almost every time.

For Manchester City, their struggles against teams with physically dominant and technically proficient players continued. They appeared to regain some control in the second half, but costly individual mistakes once again proved their undoing. The scoreline won’t help Pep Guardiola and his team’s morale, and there will certainly be a growing acknowledgment that, with so many ongoing issues, this season is one they may simply have to endure.



Use the arrows to scroll through all available match plots. Click to enlarge.
Check the match plots page for plots of other matches.

Comments

Be the first to comment on this article

Leave a Reply

Go to TOP